Christ-centered wisdom for real life.
Practical, biblical counsel you can trust.
Get it free in your inbox.
Sign Up
Christ-centered wisdom for real life.
Practical, biblical counsel you can trust.
Get it free in your inbox.
Sign Up
0
Photo: ©PeopleImages from Getty Images Signature via Canva.com
This intersection is where Marge finds herself with Mable. And her story is the story of thousands of well-meaning believers who love deeply, and carry the weight of someone else’s stubbornness as though it were their burden to fix. This chapter is for them, for those who need to know when to lean in and when to step back. Because sometimes the hardest act of faith is letting go, not holding on.
For four years, Mable has made her rounds: four counselors, two churches, three rehab centers, and a revolving door of “best friends.” Each time, she professes repentance, sheds enough tears to appear broken, and strings together words that sound humble. Then comes the cycle: She lies. She expresses remorse. She manipulates. She “repents.” She gets angry. She regrets it. She goes on a binge. She apologizes. She collapses again. This cycle is not a cycle of repentance; it is a cycle of self-deception and other-deception. And now Marge finds herself caught in Mable’s cycle, and she is exhausted, but here’s the twist: Marge is kind, merciful, and generous. She is not naïve, but she loves the underdog. Her college years were filled with ministry to the homeless, outreach to the addicted, and compassion for the broken.
Helping the weak is woven into the fabric of her identity, but Mable is unraveling all of that. Mable is teaching Marge one of the most sobering truths of Christian ministry: You cannot love someone into repentance, and you cannot will someone into wanting help. You can water, plant, warn, weep, plead, teach, call, intercede, and stand with them through battles. But you cannot bend their will into obedience. That role belongs to God alone. One of Marge’s biggest mistakes is something almost all caring Christians do: she interprets Mable’s life through her own lens. This interpretive error is natural, but it creates devastation. Marge thinks like this:
Her perspectives seem like biblical logic, but biblical logic applied to an unrepentant person becomes faulty logic because Scripture does not govern the unrepentant person. Their desires do. It’s similar to a Christian saying, “If God’s Word is true, why doesn’t everyone follow it?” That’s an honest question, but the premise is wrong. People don’t reject the Bible because it makes no sense. They reject it because their hearts prefer darkness to light (John 3:19–20). So when Marge assumes that repentance is “common sense,” she is projecting her regenerate instincts onto someone who doesn’t share those instincts. Regenerate hearts run to repentance. Unregenerate or resistant hearts run from it. To expect an unrepentant heart to behave like a regenerate heart is to walk into heartbreak.
Some people choose death knowingly, repeatedly, and stubbornly. They choose it with their desires, their habits, their lies, their relationships, and their decisions. And nothing you do can override that choice. Joshua told Israel to choose life (Joshua 24:15), implying that many would not. Deuteronomy 30 warns that the way of obedience leads to life and blessing, but the way of rebellion leads to death and curse. The battlefield of spiritual warfare is littered with casualties, not because God is insufficient, but because the human heart is deceitful, stubborn, and blind without His grace. When you are discipling someone who is actively choosing destruction, that truth should sober and protect you from the arrogance of thinking, “If I just try harder, I can save them.” You cannot. Mable is choosing destruction. And Marge is choosing to enter the war beside her. But Marge is fighting the wrong battle, with the wrong weapons, based on the wrong assumptions. She thinks Mable merely needs help. But Mable needs a heart transplant, not a hero.
Many Christians fall into a trap in which love becomes obsession, and concern becomes responsibility. You track their progress as though you will be evaluated on the results. When their life becomes the compass for your emotional stability, you have crossed the line from helper to controller. Marge started with compassion. But as the months went on, her compassion became entanglement. She was no longer merely helping Mable; she was trying to carry Mable, drag Mable, hold Mable together with her bare hands. She was no longer functioning as a discipler; she was functioning as a reluctant co-sinner, an exhausted emotional hostage chained to Mable’s cycles of deceit and self-destruction. The moment someone else’s choices begin dictating your spiritual well-being, you are over-caring.
The question this chapter raises is the question every shepherd wrestles with: When is enough… enough? When do you stop? When do you pull back? When do you accept the reality of their choices? When do you release them to God? These questions are emotionally loaded, spiritually sensitive, and uniquely difficult. But if you never learn to ask them, you will break yourself in the process of trying to fix someone else. It is possible to love someone deeply and still need to stop trying to rescue them. Stopping does not mean you stop caring or praying. Stopping means you accept that helping them is no longer helping them, and continuing to engage is harming both of you. Sometimes the most spiritual thing you can do is release someone to God’s judgment, God’s timing, and God’s plan, whether that involves repentance or discipline.
Marge is not wrong for loving Mable. She is wrong to assume it is her job to hold Mable together, manage her repentance, and ensure her sanctification. Marge’s exhaustion is a symptom of a deeper theological problem: she unknowingly elevated herself into a role God never assigned to her. If you find yourself in that same place, hear this clearly: You are not responsible for someone else’s repentance. You are responsible for your obedience. You will stand before the Lord and give an account for your faithfulness, not their outcome. Your rest comes from trusting God with your destiny. And sometimes the greatest evidence of your faith is stepping back, not out of apathy, but out of reverence for the God who alone can save.
Few things are as agonizing as loving someone who refuses to change. Your heart stretches and your hopes rise and fall. You pray harder, plead more earnestly, and try new strategies, only to watch the person you love make the same self-destructive choices, “repent,” relapse, repeat, rewind, and relive the same cycle again. That is where Marge finds herself with Mable. Her heart aches. She started hopeful, persuaded that this time would be different, that this counseling relationship would be redemptive, that this friendship would move the needle—only to realize, nine months later, that the cycle wasn’t broken. Mable wasn’t changing and the trajectory wasn’t shifting.
And now Marge is facing the hard lesson every discipler must eventually learn: the person you love most has the right to define the relationship, and sometimes their choices force you to redefine your expectations. This redefinition is not cynicism but biblical realism. It is accepting the God-given limits of human responsibility. It is learning how to stay available without being controlled and engaged without being entangled. You do not get to determine the nature of the relationship you have with an unrepentant person. They do. Their choices draw the lines. Their decisions set the terms. Their willingness—or unwillingness—to change creates the relational landscape you must walk on. Marge desperately wants a certain kind of relationship with Mable, one rooted in mutual trust, humility, shared growth, and true repentance. But that is not the relationship Mable is defining. Through her choices, deception, manipulation, binges, and refusal to embrace genuine change, Mable has made clear the sort of relational dynamic she is choosing:
Every time Mable chooses sin over repentance, she draws a line in the sand. That line tells Marge exactly where she stands and what she is willing to do. It tells Marge, “I want your support, not your counsel. I want your empathy, not your accountability.” And here is the hard truth: you cannot build a healthy, redemptive relationship on the quicksand of someone else’s unrepentant, self-destructive choices. You can love them, pray for them, warn them, speak truth to them, and walk with them up to a point. But you cannot force them to change. And you cannot ignore the relational limitations that their own behavior defines.
Marge’s motives are good; her methods are off. She loves Mable sincerely but not biblically. She is crossing the boundary from Christlike compassion into unbiblical responsibility. She is operating with a love that is sub-biblical—not sinful, but not whole, either. Biblical love is always:
A love without limits becomes a trap. Marge must guard her heart, not from Mable as a person, but from the ways her own care can become unwise, unhelpful, and unhealthy. Marge’s love for Mable blinds her to Mable’s rebellion. Marge is leaning too heavily on Mable’s repentance, as though there were no other possible outcome. She is not considering that Mable may choose death, and that she has the God-given right to make that catastrophic decision. It is possible to be so desperate for someone’s change that you become spiritually unwell yourself. At that point, the issue is not them; it is you.
The solution, however, is not for Marge to abandon Mable. Love does not walk away simply because the other person walks in darkness. But love does adjust, redefine, create space, and set limits when needed. There is a time to lean in, and there is a time to step back. And there is a time—though painful—to let consequences fall where they fall. Marge must create space, not as punishment, but as a sober acknowledgment that Mable has chosen to define the relationship in a way that prevents true intimacy, accountability, or discipleship. Space gives Marge room to breathe, prevents over-involvement, helps her regain perspective, protects her from manipulation, and reminds her who the true Savior is. Space is not unloving, but often wisdom in action.
One of the most important discipleship skills you will ever develop is the ability to draw lines, to determine where your responsibility ends and where God’s responsibility begins. A seasoned counselor told me once: “Every counseling case is a sad story. You must learn how to listen deeply without being devoured.” That is the truth. The counselor’s chair is not comfortable. It is a frontline trench. People do not come to you with victories and celebrations; they come with offenses, brokenness, addictions, sin patterns, marital turmoil, emotional collapse, and lingering trauma. And if you are not careful, their story will become your story. Their sin will shape your mental attitude. Every counselor, discipler, pastor, and friend must learn to pray something like this:
“Father, show me where to draw the lines. Help me care without being controlled. Teach me how to love without losing myself. Give me compassion without foolishness. Give me guidelines without harshness. Give me wisdom to say yes, and grace to say no. Make me a planter and waterer, not a mini-messiah.”
If you don’t pray something like that, you will not survive the emotional burden of soul care. People’s sin will crush you, and people’s rebellion will overwhelm you. The very compassion God gave you will become a snare rather than a strength.
Even after drawing wise guidelines, another step remains: learning to rest in the mysteries of God’s providence. There are things the Lord is doing in the lives of those you love that you will never understand. His ways are higher than yours and His plans stretch beyond your sightlines. His purposes include things that confuse, grieve, and perplex you. Even the sins of others—even their rebellion—fit into His sovereign plan. This hard truth is not passive resignation. It is humble acceptance. God raised Pharaoh to fulfill His purposes (Exodus 9:16).
God permitted Judas to betray His Son. God used the wickedness of men to accomplish redemption. God permitted the apostles to be confused, scattered, and shocked when the Messiah died. God allowed His Son to be crushed by sinful men to fulfill His eternal design (Isaiah 53:10). If God can use the wickedness of Pharaoh, the betrayal of Judas, and the cowardice of the apostles for His great glory, He can use the sinful and even destructive choices of Mable for His purposes.
People’s choices never overturn the sovereignty of God. Their rebellion never thwarts His plan. Even their rejection never diminishes the glory He will extract from their lives—one way or another. All things—good and evil, obedience and rebellion, repentance and stubbornness—will glorify the Lord, whether through mercy or judgment, which does not make the angst go away. But it does bring peace, clarity, and a kind of rest that allows you to love without trying to control. In the end, Marge must do two things:
She must accept that she cannot engineer Mable’s repentance and must embrace the truth that she cannot take responsibility for Mable’s choices. She must also surrender her need to see change in order to trust God. She must let go of her frantic desire for results, and find peace in knowing that God will glorify Himself either through Mable’s repentance or through Mable’s judgment. That is the essence of biblical soul care: faithful obedience, not forced outcomes.
This chapter hits close to home for many. If you want to discern whether you are in Marge’s shoes, start here:
Rick launched the Life Over Coffee global training network in 2008 to bring hope and help for you and others by creating resources that spark conversations for transformation. His primary responsibilities are resource creation and leadership development, which he does through speaking, writing, podcasting, and educating.
In 1990 he earned a BA in Theology and, in 1991, a BS in Education. In 1993, he received his ordination into Christian ministry, and in 2000 he graduated with an MA in Counseling from The Master’s University. In 2006 he was recognized as a Fellow of the Association of Certified Biblical Counselors (ACBC).
